PRISONS

THE POLICE

DATA COLLECTION & REPORTING

SAFEGUARDING

REPORTS & CONSULTATION SUBMISSIONS

MEDIA & EVENTS

HOW TO HELP

TWITTER

USA

EXCLUDING FEMALE OFFENDERS APPENDIX 5

Statement by Rhona Hotchkiss, Former Prison Governor:

“I was a Prison Governor with the Scottish Prison Service for 10 years until I retired in 2019 and in that time was in charge of prisons that held men only, women only and one that had units for both. When I started with the Service, transgender prisoners were a rarity but when I left there were 22 to 23 males self-identifying as women, although only one of the transwomen I met, or was aware of, had a Gender Recognition Certificate, that is, the rest were self-identifying. These males were the equivalent of 6% of the female prison population, although not all were at that time being held in the female estate. The vast majority of males identifying as transgender in prison had never done so prior to coming into prison.Both of the female prisons/units I was Governor in Charge of held transwomen and without exception this caused issues for the women they were accommodated with. This included:

• the trivial but real consternation of seeing a transwoman win the annual women’s gym competition
• the discomfort and distress caused to women who had been traumatised at the hands of men and women who had mental health issues who often struggled to understand why ‘men’ were being permitted to share what can be quite intimate living facilities and why they were not allowed to say so or question
• having to use non-lockable shower cubicles where the transwomen could look over the door or push it open at any time
• women being forced to witness sexualised behaviour on the part of the transwomen, for example a transwoman who walked around wearing tight leggings with an obvious erection, a transwoman who talked loudly on the phone to their partner outside, describing what ‘she’ would do to them with their penis when ‘she’ got out
• women who were retraumatised by aggressive, violent behaviour on the part of transwomen, triggering past abuses
• threats of rape to vulnerable women (and female staff) from a transwoman who decided they were male again and was demanding to be moved back to a male prison immediately.

No-one is suggesting that all women in prison are vulnerable all of the time but the vast majority have experienced abuse at the hands of men in the past and are as a group vulnerable, needing privacy in the same way as women in wider society are vulnerable, hence the reason they need segregated space. It is telling that there would be an automatic presumption against moving a ‘transman’ to the male estate because of the inherent risk to them but the same consideration is not made when locating a male bodied person with or without a GRC in the female estate. The truth remains that even transwomen who did not behave in an overtly threatening or sexualised way towards women prisoners cause issues by dint of their maleness alone.”

Statement by anonymous staff member, England:

“I was a peripatetic teacher in a women’s prison, two days a week for three years, including a time when trans-identified males were accommodated in the prison. This was very unsettling for the women I taught. They told me how unsafe it made them feel. Many of the women had experienced abuse and violence at the hands of men in their lives before prison and were very wary of being around people they knew to have committed crimes of violence, including sexual violence. One said to me: ‘it’s like putting a fox in the hen house’.

All my training on working in prisons emphasised the vulnerability of women prisoners. Teachers and other prison staff are trained to recognise and work appropriately with trauma, knowing that most women in prison have experienced some kind of trauma, often violence or abuse by men. Given the high prevalence of male violence in the life experiences of women in prison, a safe space away from the threat of male violence or manipulation is understood to be an essential part of their healing and rehabilitation.

Other prison staff I spoke shared my concerns and thought the impact on women of housing trans-identified males in a women’s prison had not been adequately assessed or sufficient importance attached to the issues of female safety and rehabilitation.”

Statement by FDJ, female former offender, England:

“Being in prison with male prisoners, you always feel on edge. You know something could happen at any time. We know they are not women. They are physically threatening and aggressive. I was sexually assaulted and I am not the only woman who has been. They haven’t had surgery and they expose themselves. One of them had been told he couldn’t shower at the same time as us women. He made a formal complaint and said this was a breach of his human rights. So now he is allowed to shower with us. And because he now has that right, the other males have that right too. There’s only a shower curtain between us. He moves the curtain so we can all see his penis when he is washing himself or shaving his legs. This is disgusting and I think it is disgusting that the prison allows this.

We can’t complain about anything. They are very well protected and it feels like our rights as women just don’t count. We have to call them ‘she’ and ‘her’ and have to use their female names. If we don’t, we are punished and lose our enhanced prisoner or D-Category status. It is horrible to do that to women.

I am very upset that I lost my legal case. I can’t understand how anyone can say that imprisoning males alongside women is the right thing to do. The prisoner who attacked me was convicted of the most serious sexual offences against girls and still has his penis. How can the government say that putting him in prison with women is the right thing to do? It’s not. I am out of prison now. But I think about all the other women still in prison who have to live with these males. This is dangerous, disgusting and wrong.”