PRISONS IN SCOTLAND
The practice of housing males who identify as women in women’s prisons in the UK is not new. It goes back at least to the 1980s. This history is set out in a paper by Professor Michael Biggs, Queer Theory and the Transition from Sex to Gender in English Prisons. Biggs provides an excellent overview of the criteria that allow males to be housed in women’s prisons and how these have changed from genital surgery to possession of a GRC to gender identity.
Prisons in Scotland are a devolved matter and are covered by separate legislation and policy to prisons in England and Wales.
Scottish Prison Service Policy
The policy framework, Gender Identity and Gender Reassignment Policy for those in our Custody, was published by the Scottish Prison Service in 2014.
This policy aims to ensure that individuals who identify as transgender people or who intend to undergo, are undergoing or have undergone gender reassignment receive respect and fairness at all times from the Scottish Prison Service.
The purpose of this policy document is to: provide accurate and current information for all SPS employees in relation to gender reassignment and gender identity equality and human rights; outline the SPS procedures to be followed in the event of a transgender person being brought into custody; enable all people in custody within SPS custody to be treated fairly and without discrimination or harassment on grounds of gender identity and gender reassignment.
The position on housing prisoners who identify as transgender is straightforward. Prisoners are to be housed according to their ‘social gender’:
The accommodation provided must be the one that best suits the person in custody’s needs and should reflect the gender in which the person in custody is currently living.
No distinction is made between male prisoners with a GRC and those without. Similarly, no distinction is made between male prisoners who have had ‘reassignment’ surgery and those who have not:
A male-to-female person in custody living permanently as a woman without genital surgery should be allocated to a female establishment. She should not be automatically regarded as posing a high sexual offence risk to other people in custody and should not be subject to any automatic restrictions of her association with other people in custody. However, if there is clear evidence that she, as an individual, may pose a sexual offence risk, then this should be dealt with as for any other person in custody posing a risk. Only where a risk assessment determines it is justified, should she be subject to increased staff supervision or restrictions of her association with other people in custody.
Accommodation may initially be single-cell. Whether or not a male prisoner who is ‘living as a woman’ shares accommodation with a female prisoner, is decided primarily on the basis of the risk this poses to the male prisoner. The needs of the women are secondary.
The development, evaluation and implementation of the policy, which was written by James Morton of Scottish Trans Alliance, the logo of which features prominently on the front cover, has been the subject of much criticism. You can read about this and how the Scottish Prison Service has overlooked the sex-based needs of women in prison in our report published in November 2021, Excluding Female Offenders in Policy & Practice.
In 2018, the Scottish Prison Service announced that the policy would be reviewed. KPSS, together with other women’s rights groups, was included in the external stakeholders’ consultation in the summer of 2021. At the time of writing, Autumn 2023, the revised policy is still nowhere to be seen.
The Prison & Young Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Rules 2011
Read the 2011 Act.
Notwithstanding that at Article 6, the protected characteristics in Equality Act 2010 are correctly identified (the protected characteristics of relevance being sex and gender reassignment), the prison rules are specified in respect of gender, not sex. This includes:
- Article 14: categorisation of prisoners
- Article 15: prisoner allocation
- Article 92: searching of prisoners
- Article 93: compulsory testing for controlled drugs
- Article 94: compulsory testing for alcohol
- Article 106: searching of visitors
- Article 108: searching of specified persons
- Article 142: searching of officers
However, in the 2006 Act, which the 2011 Act replaced, the prison rules are specified in respect of sex. Gender is not mentioned. This includes:
- Article 13: classification of prisoners
- Article 14: allocation
- Article 102: searching of visitors
- Article 104: searching of persons providing contracted out services
- Article 106: searching of prisoners
- Article 109: compulsory testing for controlled drugs
- Article 108: compulsory testing for alcohol
- Article 151: searching of officers and employees
The 2006 Act was a replacement for the 1994 Act. In that Act, the prison rules are also specified in respect of sex. Gender is not mentioned.
There appears to have been a deliberate decision to replace sex with gender for the purposes of the prison rules (notwithstanding the specification of the protected characteristics in Equality Act 2010).
This, of course, paves the way for prison policies subsequent to the 2011 Act to be framed in terms of gender, not sex. Indeed, it indicates the necessity for policies to ignore sex in favour of gender.
The importance of not allowing sex to be replaced by gender in legislation was made clear in 2020 when Johann Lamont MSP brought her six word amendment for the word “gender” substitute “sex”, to the The Forensic Medical Services (Victims of Sexual Offences) (Scotland) Bill. This amendment, which passed by 113 votes to 9, ensured that victims of rape and sexual assault could choose the sex of the person examining them after an attack.
The overwhelming success of that amendment clearly demonstrates the importance of transparency and scrutiny. However, we discovered from information disclosed in response to a Freedom of Information Access Request we submitted that there had been no process of consultation or scrutiny when the change had been made to replace “sex” with “gender” in the 2011 Scottish Prison Rules. We asked for all reports, documents, submissions and correspondence that had informed the decision to make this change. We received back a single sheet of A4 paper.
Adam Graham / Isla Bryson, January 2023
At the end of January 2023, double rapist Adam Graham AKA Isla Bryson was sent to Cornton Vale women’s prison. Graham/Bryson had begun identifying as transgender after he was charged. A matter of days later the transfer to the female estate of the violent male offender held on Order for Lifelong Restriction Andrew Burns AKA Tiffany Scott was approved. It was only after sustained political and public pressure, that Graham was sent to the male estate at HMP Edinburgh and the transfer for Burns cancelled.
The Bryson case shone a light on the Scottish Government’s commitment to reform the Gender Recognition Act 2004 via the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill. This Bill, which sought to introduce a policy of self ID, as well as lower the age at which someone could apply for a GRC to 16 and reduce the required waiting period to 3 months, had passed in December 2022, although it was subsequently blocked by the UK Government under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998. Efforts to amend the Bill by introducing protections for women and girls against the possibility of males taking advantage of the provisions to act in bad faith had failed. It later emerged that Bryson, whilst awaiting trial, had been accepted onto a beauty course that has involved practical assignments where the students had been in a state of undress. Although Bryson had not been issued with a gender recognition certificate, neither were there any reports that he had applied for one, the case was seen by the media, the public and by politicians as an example of a man who was simply “trying it on”.
Over the days and weeks that followed, questions were asked at Holyrood:
Russell Findlay Urgent Question, 25/01/23
First Minister’s Question, Douglas Ross MSP, 26/01/23
Russell Findlay MSP Speech, 31/01/23
Statement from Justice Secretary Keith Brown, 31/01/23
First Minister’s Question, Urgent Question from Douglas Ross MSP, 09/02/23
First Minister’s Question, Douglas Ross MSP, 02/02/23
The Scottish Prison Service and Justice Secretary responded by setting in place an interim measure that initial allocation for new intake of prisoners who identify as transgender will be to the estate that matches their “birth gender” and that no prisoner who identifies as transgender with a conviction for violence against women and girls would be transferred to the female estate.
They also launched a Lessons Learned Review. This was concluded on 8th February 2023 with the intention that a Standard Operating Procedure be written on the basis of the findings, which would also be fed into the review of the Scottish Prison Service policy. However, the decision was made that the final report would not be released, even to the members of the Criminal Justice Committee. In our opinion, it is wholly unsatisfactory that the full report of the Lessons Learned Review will not be published and will not be subject to independent scrutiny. As it stands, this Lessons Learned Review was commissioned, produced, assessed, read, summarised and kept confidential by precisely those whose actions and decisions were called into question necessitating the review. This lack of independent scrutiny is a serious failing and calls into question the adequacy and sufficiency of every aspect of the Lessons Learned Review.
The Criminal Justice Committee met on 22nd February 2023 to hear evidence from Teresa Medhurt CEO of the Scottish Prison Service and Keith Brown the then Justice Secretary. In our view, this meeting provided little clarity. Watch a recording of that meeting.






