PRISONS

THE POLICE

DATA COLLECTION & REPORTING

SAFEGUARDING

REPORTS & CONSULTATION SUBMISSIONS

MEDIA & EVENTS

HOW TO HELP

TWITTER

USA

DATA COLLECTION BY PRISONS

IN ENGLAND & WALES

The MoJ & HMPPS Policy Framework The Care and Management of Individuals who are Transgender sets out the requirements for record-keeping and the collection of data on prisoners who identify as transgender.

Until 2021 it was not possible to ascertain the total number of prisoners who identify as transgender. This was because when a prisoner had been issues with a GRC, that prisoner was only recorded in the data pertaining to the sex with which the prisoner identifies. Therefore, when a male prisoner obtained a GRC, he was recorded as female/woman in all records: that he is of the male sex could only be recorded with his permission. If he withheld permission, as was his right, the fact that his sex is male could not be recorded or used in any way.

At the most fundamental level this meant that it was impossible to ascertain the number of males who were held in women’s prisons. Only those who did not have a GRC could be counted: those males in the female estate who had a GRC were ‘hidden’ in the statistics and data because they were recorded as female, and only as female.

It was also impossible to analyse the impact of housing males in the female estate: the impact of housing males with a GRC in women’s prisons was ‘hidden’ because these males are recorded as female. In answer to a Freedom of Information Access request we submitted, the Ministry of Justice confirmed that if a male with a GRC assaulted a woman he is imprisoned with, the incident would be recorded as an assault committed by a woman.

The lack of data collection on GRC holders was called into question in R (FDJ) v Secretary of State for Justice (2021). This judicial review was brought by FDJ, a female prisoner who had been sexually assaulted by a male prisoner who identified as transgender and who had a GRC. This male prisoner had been convicted of serious sexual offences against women and was held in the general female population of the female estate. During the hearing, the judges expressed incredulity at the lack of data on GRC holders and the Secretary of State for Justice was ordered to provide a complete breakdown of all data on GRC holders in prison. Subsequently, the Ministry of Justice undertook that from 2021 onwards, the number of GRC holders would be included in the data that are reported annually. On 1st October 2021, The Gender Recognition (Disclosure of Information) (England and Wales) Order 2021 I 2021/1020 came into force and introduced a further exception to section 22 of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 where the disclosure of protected information is necessary for the management of offenders and arrangements related to their probation.

The 2021 and 2022 HMPPS Offender Equalities Annual Report provided data on the number of prisoners with a GRC, although in neither year was the figure disaggregated by sex registered at birth (or transgender identity) or by prison estate. We understand that there may be further changes to the way that data are reported in 2023.

IN SCOTLAND

The Prison & Young Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Rules 2011 stipulate at Article 14 that prisoners shall be categorised according to gender, not sex. This was a change from the 2006 and 1994 versions of this Act, where the prison rules were specified in respect of sex. Gender was not mentioned. This change paves the way for prison policy and practice subsequent to the 2011 Act to be framed in terms of gender, not sex. Indeed, it indicates the necessity for policies to ignore sex in favour of gender.

The Scottish Prison Service has undertaken to publish data on the number of prisoners who identify as transgender on a quarterly basis. These reports can be found here, where data on the “social gender” prisoners are living in are reported.

It is unknown how the Scottish Prison Service record prisoners who have been issued with a GRC: are these prisoners included within the data for prisoners who identify as transgender, or are they included with the data on the sex with which the prisoner identifies? The SPS did not introduce an SSI to mirror the October 2021 SI that was introduced in England and Wales. An attempt to introduce this SSI at the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill Stage 3 debate at the end of 2022 was unsuccessful.