PRISONS

THE POLICE

DATA COLLECTION & REPORTING

SAFEGUARDING

REPORTS & CONSULTATION SUBMISSIONS

MEDIA & EVENTS

HOW TO HELP

TWITTER

USA

HOW POLICE FORCES IN ENGLAND & WALES RECORD SUSPECTS’ SEX IN CRIME & INCIDENT REPORTING

Sex registered at birth is a fundamental demographic and explanatory variable which is established throughout the criminal justice system as important to analysing patterns of offending, pathways into offending and risk. These differences between males and females underpin policy and practice throughout every aspect of the criminal justice system.

Despite the recognised importance of sex registered at birth, the Home Office does not currently mandate how police forces should record a suspect’s sex. Freedom of Information Access Requests indicate that many police forces in England and Wales record suspects’ gender identity in lieu of sex registered at birth, frequently on the basis of self-identification and including where the suspected offence is rape. Some forces stated that they record the sex of a suspect who identifies as non-binary as indeterminate, unspecified or other. Of the 25 forces that answered our questions, only one police force stated that they record sex registered at birth as standard.

Offending patterns differ significantly between males and females with males committing the large majority of offences. Some offence categories are very rarely committed by females. This means that the allocation of even one or two cases of male offending to the female subgroup, on the basis of the suspect’s gender identity, may have a significant impact on the data, compromising both its reliability and its utility to service development.

The data recording decisions made by individual police forces affect the criminal justice system more widely. This is because data collected by police forces are transferred over onto other data management systems, including the Police National Computer (one of the main sources of information for Disclosure and Barring Service checks), the Annual Data Requirement (provided to the Home Office for research and statistical purposes) and Magistrates and Crown Courts case management systems. The decisions police forces make concerning data recording are key.

Guidance issued by the College of Policing, HM Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services and the UK Statistical Authority recognises the importance of sex, its significance to policing and the need to record sex as one of the protected characteristics in the Equality Act 2010 for reasons that include forces public sector equality duty and other legal obligations under the Equality Act 2010.

However, from April 2022, the Home Office has requested that police forces, on a voluntary basis, record the gender identity (legal gender) of suspects and victims where they are in receipt of a gender recognition certificate. Sex registered at birth should be recorded in all other cases. This request is likely to be rolled out as guidance next year. This decision sets a data collection precedent which will mandate the loss of data and which is out of step with existing guidance and evidence. By overwriting sex registered at birth with legal gender, this remains insufficient to ensure the collection of accurate, relevant and reliable data on offending.

Accurate, relevant and reliable data on offending is a legitimate public interest. The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that the interests of data collection are best served when police forces collect data on suspects’ sex registered at birth. Our recommendations in the accompanying Report are grounded in the collection of data on the protected characteristics in the Equality Act 2010. These include that the Home Office issue clear centralised guidance which mandates police forces to record suspects’ sex registered at birth: the lawfulness of this is clear, including where a suspect is in receipt of a gender recognition certificate. Additional data on gender reassignment as a separate protected characteristic should also be collected.

You can read our report on How Police Forces in England & Wales Record Suspects’ Sex in Crime & Incident Reporting.

You can read our supplementary document reporting How Police Scotland Records Suspects’ Sex.

We will be submitting these FOIAs annually in order to track any changes in how police forces record data on suspects.