PRISONS

THE POLICE

DATA COLLECTION & REPORTING

SAFEGUARDING

REPORTS & CONSULTATION SUBMISSIONS

MEDIA & EVENTS

HOW TO HELP

TWITTER

USA

DISCLOSURE SCOTLAND CHECKS

Scotland operates a separate system for disclosure and barring. Operationally, the two systems share similarities, including permitting applicants to conceal previous identities.

The operation of Disclosure Scotland results in more widespread safeguarding loopholes than DBS because certificates issued by Disclosure Scotland only display the applicant’s current name. By contrast, DBS certificates display all names the applicant has ever used (provided these have been disclosed during the application process). DBS will only withhold previously used names where an applicant has changed gender and opted to use the Sensitive Applications Route.

Our first recommendation is that Disclosure Scotland certificates display all names the applicant has ever used. This change must apply to all individuals, with no exceptions.

As with the DBS, Disclosure Scotland enables individuals to apply for a Disclosure check using identity documents that can be changed to reflect a change of gender on the basis of self-declaration. The enhanced privacy rights that apply when an individual changes gender, which do not apply when an individual only changes their name, mean that an individual is able to sever any connection with an existing record of offending with a far greater degree of confidence that their previous identity will be undetected.

Disclosure Scotland applications require the individual to provide their National Insurance number. NI numbers are allocated for life and are unique to each individual. They do not change should an individual change identity, no matter what that change of identity consists of nor how the change of identity is affected, be that via self-declaration, deed poll, statutory declaration or gender recognition certificate. An individual’s new details may be recorded against their existing number, but records of previously used identities will not be deleted. Rather they are retained, together with the relevant dates of use, until 50 years after the individual’s death. NI numbers, therefore, enable all information held about an individual to be tied together in a way that cannot be circumvented by changing identity. At present, Disclosure Scotland relies on applicant honesty to provide all previously used names. Yet, as the Safeguarding Alliance reports, safeguarding cannot be reliant on applicants choosing to do the right thing. Those who are motivated to conceal their previous identity in order to evade safeguarding will simply choose to do the wrong thing: that it is an offence not to reveal previous names has been demonstrated to be no deterrent.

Currently, although an applicant undergoing a Disclosure Scotland check is required to provide their NI number, checks against this are not routinely undertaken. They only take place in very specific, arguably exceptional, circumstances for example where a close match needs to be confirmed or eliminated.

Our second recommendation is that full use be made of NI numbers:

Disclosure Scotland checks should include a check against the applicant’s NI number in order that all identities the applicant has used can be retrieved and checked against data held on the Police National Computer, local police force system and the Barred Lists

Individuals placed on the Barred Lists should have their NI number recorded against their name
When an individual makes an application to change their identity on their passport or driving licence, or any other document that may be used to establish identity, the applicant should be required to provide their NI number in order that these identity changes can be included on their NI number record

Disclosure Scotland operates a confidential process for applicants who have changed gender, including on the basis of self-declaration. As with the DBS Sensitive Applications Route, this means that applicants who have changed gender are excused from providing previous names on the application form in the usual way and are instead able to provide these separately and in confidence to Disclosure Scotland in order that the relevant checks may be made. Disclosure Scotland agree to conceal the applicant’s sex registered at birth from the certificate, instead displaying their gender identity or legally recognised acquired gender, where the applicant has been issued with a gender recognition certificate.

Our third recommendation is that Disclosure Scotland certificates display the individual’s sex as registered at birth and that the data field currently labelled ‘gender’ is renamed ‘sex’.

Read our Supplementary Document: Disclosure Scotland Checks and Identity Verification.