PRISONS IN ENGLAND
The practice of housing males who identify as women in women’s prisons in the UK is not new. It goes back at least to the 1980s. This history is set out in a paper by Professor Michael Biggs, Queer Theory and the Transition from Sex to Gender in English Prisons. Biggs provides an excellent overview of the criteria that allow males to be housed in women’s prisons and how these have changed from genital surgery to possession of a GRC to gender identity.
The MoJ Policy
At the end of March 2023, the MoJ issued the revised version of The Care and Management of Individuals who are Transgender. This is the policy which sets out the criteria that male prisoners must meet in order to be allocated to a women’s prison (and the criteria that female prisoners must meet in order to be housed with men). The policy applies to prisons, Approved Premises and the Youth Secure Estate throughout England and Wales.
Previous versions of the policy had emphasised the need to consider and balance the welfare and rights of male prisoners who identify as transgender against those of women in prison. The operation of previous versions also showed that, regardless of offending history or anatomy, male prisoners with a GRC were far more likely to be allocated to the female estate. However, the 2023 revised policy takes a different approach.
The presumption is that all male prisoners who identify as women with intact male genitalia, or who have a current or previous conviction for any violent or sexual offence (not just against women or girls) should not be held in the general women’s estate. This applies equally to those with and without a GRC: those without a GRC will be held in the male estate; those with a GRC may be held in E Wing at HMP Downview.
Exemptions to this can only be considered on recommendation of a Complex Case Board where there is a high level of confidence that the individual poses a low level of harm to women in prison. Recommendations must be referred to the HMPPS Director General of Operations for consideration and to the Secretary of State for Justice for a final decision.
The policy is retrospective meaning that for all male prisoners currently held in the female estate new allocation decisions will be made.
This policy is not perfect and still allows for male prisoners to be held alongside women. However, it is a considerable improvement and should see a significant reduction in the number of male prisoners in the female estate. It is noteworthy that the policy cuts across GRC status and places far greater emphasis on the risk to women in prison than in previous versions.
The ‘Transgender Unit’ E Wing
In 2019, Wing E at HMP Downview, a women’s prison, was re-opened as a ‘transgender unit’ to house male prisoners with a GRC who presented a risk to female prisoners too great to be managed in the normal female estate.
Some saw this as a knee-jerk response to provide a rushed ‘solution’ to the growing evidence that women in prison were at risk from male prisoners and to calm the outrage that had resulted when the male prisoner Karen White, who had been remanded to the female estate to await trial for multiple charges of rape, sexually assaulted women prisoners.
Wing E, also known as the Josephine Butler Wing, is a 16 cell unit which had previously been used to house young female offenders. Before it was repurposed to house male prisoners, there had been plans to turn it into a unit to house women who are preparing for release.
There are clear implications for women in prison when resources in the female estate are repurposed to accommodate the needs of male prisoners. Questions of resource allocation aside, is this an acceptable solution? The short answer is: no.
Read: HM Prison and Probation Service document HMP Downview Wing E Policy
Paragraph 1.1 states that the Unit is intended for:
Transgender women holding Gender Recognition Certificates who have been assessed as presenting a high risk of harm to other women in custody… where the risk cannot safely be managed on normal location within the Women’s Estate.
This policy is predicated on the ability to assess risk as being ‘too high’. However risk assessment of male prisoners with GRCs is inadequate. This is because the risk assessment tool that is used for adult men who have been convicted of sexual or sexually motivated offences is not used for males with GRCs because these prisoners are recorded as female and this tool is not to be used for female sexual offenders. Our suspicion is that ‘unmanageable risk’ needs to be demonstrated through cumulative incidents of assault against women in prison.
Paragraph 4.1 states that placement at the Unit is not intended to be permanent, rather prisoners should be assisted in progressing back into the wider female estate. Section 10.0 indicates that prisoners held at the Unit remain able to access activities within the main prison at Downview and to mix with the female prisoners for the purposes of those activities.
For these reasons we consider that the unit at Downview does not provide an acceptable solution that keeps women in prison safe.
In May 2021, the campaign group Fair Play for Women published the Equality Analysis for E Wing, which they had obtained via a Freedom of Information Access request. The following is of particular note:
In consideration of the options available to house male prisoners with a GRC, the perceived necessity for these prisoners to continue to associate with female prisoners, to have ‘equality of opportunity’ compared to female prisoners and the wish to ‘foster good relations’ between the two groups took priority over any concern for the safety of female prisoners. For this reason a bespoke unit in the male estate was rejected.
Initially, it was proposed that E Wing should house both ‘non-trans and trans’ high risk women. This would have eliminated discrimination between the two groups as ‘trans women’ would have been treated the same as ‘non-trans women’. Again, this proposal was seen to offer the advantage of fostering good relations. This was rejected as unworkable due to ‘the specific risks to other women which do in part derive from their transgender status’. We believe it is more accurate to state that the ‘specific risks’ arise because these prisoners are male.
There is scant consideration given to the safety and wellbeing of female prisoners at Downview. No account is taken to the budgetary, infrastructure or staffing costs to HMP Downview of repurposing E Wing and the consequent impact on the women held there.
Fair Play For Women report: transgender prison policy
It is possible that the 2023 MoJ policy, which sees greater restrictions placed on the ability of male prisoners who identify as transgender to be housed alongside women, will mean that greater use is made of E Wing. We will be monitoring the situation.
How Many Male Prisoners are in Women’s Prisons?
Surprisingly, it had been impossible until recently to say how many males are held in women’s prisons. This was because a male prisoner with a GRC was recorded in all records and data as a woman and as female. This meant that males with a GRC who were held in women’s prisons were effectively hidden: they wouldn’t show up as male or as transgender in any records.
In 2021, it was reported in answer to Parliamentary Question 183091 that this would be changing and that data would report on the numbers of GRC holders in prison.
On 1st October 2021, the Gender Recognition (Disclosure of Information) (England and Wales) Order 2021 SI 2021/1020 came into force. This introduced a further exception to the offence under s22 of the GRA where the disclosure of protected information is necessary for management of offenders and arrangements related to their probation. This was a significant development to permit the MoJ to publish the total number of male prisoners held in the female estate, as well as the total number of male prisoners who identify as transgender.
The 2022 HM Prison and Probation Service Offender Equalities Annual Report provides data on the number of prisoners asserting a transgender identity. In 2022, there were 230 prisoners claiming a transgender identity who had no GRC: 187 were male, 6 of whom were in the female estate; 43 were female and all of these were held in women’s prisons.
An additional 11 prisoners had a GRC. Based on data obtained in 2021, we are confident that all of these prisoners were male and that between 8 and 10 were in the female estate, giving a total of between 14 and 16 male prisoners in the female estate.
These numbers show an increase in the number of prisoners claiming a transgender identity. Interestingly, the group that shows the greatest rate of increase is females who identify as men.
On 30th November 2023, the Ministry of Justice released the HMPPS Offender Equalities Annual Report 2022 – 2023. This document, that is published annually, reports on prisoners with protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010. The data show that:
- There are 269 prisoners asserting a transgender identity who do not have a GRC. This is a 17% increase on the figure of 230 in 2022.
- The large majority of these are male & this is where the biggest increase can be seen: there are 225 male prisoners who ID as transgender (2022 = 187) compared to 44 female prisoners (2022 = 43).
- The number of GRC holders is reported separately: there are 13 prisoners who have been issued with a GRC (2022 = 11). In 2022 all of these were male prisoners and we are confident that the very large majority in 2023 are also male.
At the end of March 2023, the Ministry of Justice released the revised policy framework, The Care and Management of Individuals Who Are Transgender. This revised policy introduced additional criteria to exclude male prisoners who identify as transgender from being housed in the general population of the female estate.
The data collection exercise upon which this years HMPPS Offender Equalities Annual Report is based was carried out at the beginning of March 2023, prior to the release of the revised policy. For this reason we are ignoring the data reported on allocation of prisoners who identify as transgender: the figures the 2023 Report presents reflect the prison population under the previous policy.
We are aware that the revised policy has had a marked impact on the numbers of male prisoners in the female estate, with transfers taking place out of both the general population and E Wing. However, data demonstrating the impact of these new criteria will not be available until November 2024, when the Offender Equalities Annual Report 2023 – 2024 is released. In the meantime, we continue to monitor the situation and raise issues of concern where necessary.
What are their patterns of offending?
The HM Prison and Probation Service Offender Equalities Annual Report does not provide any information about the categories of offence committed, nor length of sentence.
The most recent data on the categories of offence committed by male prisoners who identify as transgender was given in response to Parliamentary Question 96653 and Parliamentary Question 108375 asked by Kenny MacAskill MP.
These data reveal that in 2022 there were 97 prisoners claiming a transgender identity, who do not have a GRC, where the principle offence is a sexual offence.
Of these 97, 91 or 92 are male, showing that 49% of male prisoners who identify as transgender and who have no GRC have at least one conviction for a sexual offence. This is a slight reduction on the figures for 2021 where this rate was 60% (Parliamentary Question 98878). This rate is far higher than the rate in the male prison population as a whole: around 17% of men in prison in England and Wales have been sentenced for sexual offences.
Five or 6 of the 97 prisoners are female, this means that almost 13% of female prisoners claiming a transgender identity and who have no GRC have at least one conviction for a sexual offence. This is in excess of the rate of sexual offending for the female prison population as a whole: around 2% of women in prison in England and Wales have been sentenced for sexual offences.
Searching
Procedures for searching prisoners who identity as transgender are set out at section 4.14 and in Annex A of the Searching Policy Framework implemented at the beginning of 2023.
Prisoners in receipt of a GRC are entitled to be treated as their acquired gender in respect of searching. This means that male prisoners with a GRC should only be rubdown searched or full searched (strip searched) by female officers. The prisoner can only be searched by male officers, if he consents via a written Voluntary Agreement. Male prisoners with GRCs must be searched according to the searching protocol in place for female offenders. There are some differences in the searching arrangements for male and for female offenders beyond the sex of the officers who are permitted to do the searching. Where there is a difference, male offenders are subject to a higher level of searching than females. These differences are not discriminatory against men, nor are they prejudicial in favour of women. Rather, they reflect the fact that male prisoners represent a higher degree of risk than female prisoners.
Male prisoners without a GRC should be searched according to the protocol in place for male offenders. This means that rubdown searches may be carried out by either a male or a female officer and full searches should be carried out only by male staff.






