PRISONS

THE POLICE

DATA COLLECTION & REPORTING

SAFEGUARDING

REPORTS & CONSULTATION SUBMISSIONS

MEDIA & EVENTS

HOW TO HELP

TWITTER

USA

TEMPLATE LETTERS SCOTLAND

Letter: The Care & Management of Transgender Prisoners

Dear

Re: The Care and Management of Transgender Prisoners

At the end of March 2023, the Ministry of Justice issued their revised policy, The Care and Management of Individuals Who Are Transgender. This followed an extensive period of consultation spread over a period of time which saw media reports of harm caused to female offenders by male offenders who identify as transgender and who we were housed with them.

The Ministry of Justice policy states that male prisoners who identify as transgender who have been been convicted of any violent of sexual offence, not only against women, may not be housed in the general population of the female estate. As a separate provision, male prisoners who identify as transgender who retain male genitalia are similarly excluded from women’s prisons. These exclusions apply equally to those with and without a Gender Recognition Certificate. Exceptions can only be considered where there is the highest degree of confidence in only a low level of risk to women in prisons: those prisoners who are judged to meet this threshold must be signed off firstly by the Director of HMPPS and secondly by the Secretary of State for Justice.

It is with considerable dismay, that I note that the Scottish Prison Service first stated that their policy that provides for the management of prisoners who identify as transgender was under review in late 2018. The final revised policy is still nowhere to be seen. In the meantime, women in prison in Scotland are housed with male offenders convicted of the most serious violent offences, including murder. Were the Ministry of Justice policy to be in operation in Scotland, it would see the removal of all male offenders who identify as transgender back to the male estate.

The Ministry of Justice policy is the most recent globally on the management of transgender prisoners and is based on significant experience with this cohort. As such it should be viewed as authoritative.

Please could you write to Angela Constance, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs and to the Scottish Prison Service setting out my concerns and asking that the Scottish Prison Service put in place provisions that mirror those that have been introduced south of the border.

Kind regards

Letter: Disclosure Scotland Checks & Change of Identity

Dear

Re: Disclosure Scotland Checks and Change of Identity

Disclosure Scotland plays a vital role in safeguarding by processing criminal record checks for individuals who have applied to work in roles where safeguarding considerations apply. However, where applicants submit identity documents for Disclosure Scotland checks that display a new identity, safeguarding loopholes are created because the applicant can sever the link with any existing records of offending.

The most wide-reaching loopholes are created where individuals simultaneously change both their name and gender. This is because of the exceptional enhanced privacy rights Disclosure Scotland grants to individuals who change their gender. The result is that identity verification is compromised, meaning that there is no guarantee that the information returned during a Disclosure Scotland check and displayed on the certificate will be accurate or complete. I am sure you are aware of the recent debates in Westminster concerning the ability of registered sex offenders to change their name. However, change of gender has received less focus and the risk posed by other individuals, not on the sex offenders register, changing their identity has been overlooked.

Any individual can easily, and for any reason, change their name and gender on documents commonly used to establish identity via a process of self-declaration: no gender recognition certificate is required. These documents, that include passport and driving licence, can be presented for the purposes of a Disclosure Scotland check and will show the individual’s new name and their self-declared gender instead of their sex.

Exceptional enhanced privacy rights allow an applicant who has changed gender to withhold their previous names during the normal application process. This right is not given to anyone else: disclosing previous identities is a key component of safeguarding.

Applicants who change their gender are also permitted to conceal their sex and the Disclosure Scotland certificate issued will display their self-declared gender or legally recognised acquired gender instead. The importance of sex to safeguarding means that for all other applicants, their sex is always displayed.

The current operation of the Disclosure Scotland regime means that organisations requesting Disclosure Scotland checks cannot have confidence in the information that is disclosed.

A recent report by the campaign group Keep Prisons Single Sex, Disclosure Scotland Checks and Identity Verification, proposes:

  • Mandatory use of National Insurance numbers for Disclosure Scotland checks and identity changes
  • Disclosure Scotland certificates display sex registered at birth
  • Disclosure Scotland certificates display other names used for all applicants, including those who have changed gender as part of changing identity

I am sure you will agree that in order to be effective, the rules of safeguarding must apply equally to everyone. Whenever the members of one group are excused from the normal requirements of safeguarding, a loophole is created that is ripe for exploitation.

Please could you write to Natalie Don, the Minister for Children and Young People, asking that she give consideration to these proposals.

Kind regards

Letter: Recording Suspects’ Sex in Crime & Incident Reporting

Dear

Re: Recording Suspects’ Sex in Crime and Incident Reporting

Sex registered at birth is a powerful predictor of outcomes in almost every dimension of social life. Sex registered at birth is established throughout the criminal justice system as important to analysing patterns of offending, pathways into offending and risk. These differences between males and females underpin policy and practice throughout the criminal justice system.

A recent report by Keep Prisons Single Sex, How Police Scotland Records Suspects’ Sex reports that Police Scotland record self-declared gender for all offences, including where the suspect has been charged with rape. Police Scotland also said that where DNA obtained from a suspect had given a scientific analysis of biological sex that did not match what had been recorded for their sex, this would not result in a correction of that record.

Offending patterns differ significantly between males and females: males commit the large majority of offences and some offence categories are only rarely committed by females. This means that allocating even 1 or 2 cases of male offending to the female subgroup, on the basis of the suspect’s gender identity, can have a significant impact on the data, compromising its reliability and its utility and relevance to service development.

The recommendations KPSS propose are grounded in the collection of data on the protected characteristics in the Equality Act 2010 and include that the Scottish Government issue clear centralised guidance that mandates police forces to record suspects’ sex registered at birth. Additional data on gender reassignment as a separate protected characteristic should also be recorded.

Accurate, relevant and reliable data on offending is a legitimate public interest. The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that the interests of data collection are best served when police forces collect data on suspects’ sex registered at birth. There is no evidence that allowing the substitution of gender identity, or legal gender where a suspect is in receipt of a gender recognition certificate, affords greater (or even equivalent) explanatory power.

Please could you write to Angela Constance, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs and to the Scottish Police Authority setting out my concerns and asking that Police Scotland be mandated to record the sex registered at birth of suspects.

Kind regards